How the three energy systems work together
Muscles use adenosine triphosphate, or ATP, to contract. They store only a small amount, so three energy systems replenish it during activity. The phosphagen system uses phosphocreatine stored in muscle. It supplies energy fastest but has the smallest capacity. The glycolytic system breaks down muscle glycogen without oxygen. It also supplies energy quickly, but fuel depletion and increasing acidity limit how long it can do so. The oxidative system uses oxygen to release energy from carbohydrate and fat. It has a large capacity, but its rate depends on oxygen delivery to the muscles. All three systems contribute to every effort. Their relative contributions change with the effort's intensity and duration.
| All-out effort lasting | Anaerobic share | Aerobic share |
|---|---|---|
| 5 seconds | 95% | 5% |
| 10 seconds | 91% | 9% |
| 30 seconds | 75% | 25% |
| 60 seconds | 58% | 42% |
| Around 80 seconds | Even | Even |
| 2 minutes | 38% | 62% |
| 5 minutes | 19% | 81% |
The table summarises just over a hundred studies of adults performing single maximal efforts. Its percentages are modelled averages from different testing protocols, not measurements of an individual rugby player. All three systems contribute throughout. In these estimates, the anaerobic contribution is larger for efforts shorter than about seventy-five seconds. The aerobic contribution becomes larger as the effort continues.
Energy demands during a rugby match
Rugby combines brief high-intensity efforts with lower-intensity movement and rest. Those efforts include strength and power actions, static work, collisions and high-speed running. A sprint to a breakdown, tackle or lineout jump lasts a few seconds and relies heavily on the phosphagen system. During a longer defensive set or phase sequence approaching a minute, the glycolytic contribution becomes more important. Longer work relies increasingly on the oxidative system. That system also supports recovery between efforts, because restoring phosphocreatine requires oxygen and time.
Mostly anaerobic
One explosive effort
In pooled adult measurements a ten-second maximal effort drew about nine tenths of its energy from the anaerobic systems, with the phosphagen system leading.
Around 80 seconds
Where the balance tips
At about eighty seconds of maximal work the aerobic and anaerobic systems supply equal shares, and everything longer is mostly aerobic.
Phosphocreatine
Muscle energy store
One thirty-second all-out sprint dropped muscle phosphocreatine to about a fifth of its resting level in the eight men who gave muscle samples.
Oxygen
Recovery
Oxygen taken up early in recovery rebuilds spent phosphocreatine, but ninety seconds after that sprint the store was only about two thirds restored.
Recovery between repeated sprints
In one study, fourteen men completed thirty-second all-out cycle sprints. Muscle samples from eight of them showed that phosphocreatine fell to about a fifth of its resting level after the sprint. It recovered to about two thirds after ninety seconds and about 85 per cent after six minutes. The recovery half-time was just under a minute. Sprint power recovered alongside phosphocreatine, rather than alongside the change in muscle acidity. With short rests between efforts, phosphocreatine may not fully recover before the next sprint.
What your position asks for
The available evidence does not give an exact aerobic and anaerobic split for each rugby position during a match. It does describe different match demands. Across fifty-one GPS studies of rugby union, backs covered more total distance, distance per minute and high-speed distance. Forwards recorded more collisions, impacts and static work.
Every position needs short explosive efforts and recovery between them. Forwards repeat short, heavy efforts with relatively little running between them, making recovery between efforts a training priority. Outside backs make fewer but faster sprints, with more running between those sprints. Their training needs to include top speed and the aerobic capacity that supports recovery.
How to train each system
Effort length, intensity and rest duration affect how much each energy system contributes to a session. The examples below use the measured effort-duration estimates and phosphocreatine recovery findings to explain those choices.
| Target | Work | Rest | Why it works |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phosphagen power | Maximal efforts of a few seconds | Several minutes, close to full recovery | After a maximal sprint, phosphocreatine was only about two thirds restored at ninety seconds. Short rests can limit the power available in the next effort. |
| Repeat-effort capacity | Short maximal efforts | Deliberately short, well under a minute | The next effort begins before full recovery, as can happen during repeated work around a breakdown. |
| Glycolytic tolerance | Hard efforts of thirty to seventy-five seconds | A few minutes between efforts | Maximal efforts in this range still use mainly anaerobic energy, with a large glycolytic contribution. |
| Aerobic base | Steady and tempo running in longer blocks | Short or none | Maximal efforts beyond about eighty seconds are mainly aerobic. The oxidative system also supports phosphocreatine recovery between shorter efforts. |